Saylor NYC Reviews

Saylor NYC has an overall rating of 3.1 based on 22 reviews. Customer feedback on Saylor NYC is mixed.

3.1/5.0

22 reviews

5 Stars

5

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

4

1 Star

4

All Saylor NYC Reviews (22)
joanlegra7611
June 03, 2026
"Delivery was a bit too unreliable"
I actually liked the clothes, but the delivery experience wasn’t great. My order arrived later than the date they originally gave me, and the tracking didn’t seem to update for a few days, so I ended up having to email to ask what was going on. It did eventually show up, and everything was fine once it arrived, but it was still frustrating. I’d probably be hesitant to order again if I needed something for a trip or an event
Wallace.feuer
June 01, 2026
"The packaging was alright overall, not terrible or..."
The packaging was alright overall, not terrible or anything!! The box did show up a little squished, which had me worried for a second... but luckily the item inside was totally fine. I just kinda expected it to feel a bit nicer for the price, you know??
NickMatin
May 27, 2026
"The return process was really simple and..."
The return process was really simple and hassle-free. I didn’t have any issues getting it done...
denise_Cornelius93
May 24, 2026
"Maybe it’s just me, but while the website..."
Maybe it’s just me, but while the website looks good and was easy to browse overall, parts of it felt a bit clunky. The photos loaded fine for me, but a few pages seemed slower than expected, and I had to click around more than I wanted to find the right sizes and styles. Checkout was fine and not confusing, so it’s definitely usable — just not the smoothest shopping experience.
William_schultz90
May 18, 2026
"Happy I grabbed it on sale"
I ended up buying a dress from saylor.nyc during one of their sales, the discount made me feel a lot better about going for it. I had been going back and forth for a bit, but once I saw the sale price show up correctly at checkout with no weird extra surprises, I felt like it was a safe buy.
The only thing that stressed me out a little was that some sizes were already sold out, so I felt like I had to decide quickly before mine disappeared too. Still, I’m happy with what I picked and feel like I got a good deal.
Amy.stewart
May 04, 2026
"They have some really cute things, and I..."
They have some really cute things, and I didn’t have a bad experience or anything. I just thought the prices were higher than I expected, so it just felt...
Beverly-spannuth
April 30, 2026
"Cute dress, but the sizing felt a little off..."
The dress is really cute and I wanted to like it, but the fit was kind of strange on me. The waist felt tight, while the top was a bit loose, so it just didn’t sit quite right... I thought about sizing up, but I’m not sure that would actually fix the issue.
SLAMA
April 29, 2026
"Okay, this dress actually holds up"
I’ve worn my saylor dress a bunch of times at this point, i’m kind of impressed. I was fully expecting some loose seams or weird stretched-out fabric after a wash because that seems to happen way too often with dresses lately, but nope. It still looks really good. The fabric feels sturdy without being heavy or annoying to wear, which is apparently not as easy to find as it should be. Overall, I’m really happy with it and it seems like it’s going to last a while.
Jonathon-brumaghim
April 21, 2026
"I had to return something, and the refund..."
I had to return something, and the refund came through faster than I expected. The whole process wasn’t totally perfect, but it was easy enough and went smoothly overall.
jimmie2001
April 10, 2026
"Cute dress, but am I missing something?"
I got a dress from saylor it looks really cute on. The style is and it photographs well, so I can see why people like it. But am I missing something with the comfort? The fabric felt fine at first, then after wearing it for a few hours, the seams started feeling a little itchy.
The fit was mostly true to size, though it felt a bit tight when I sat down. It’s not awful by any means, just not a dress I’d want to wear all day. Super piece, I just wish it was easier and more comfortable to actually wear
VickiePierson_04
March 25, 2026
"I ordered a dress from saylor, and..."
I ordered a dress from saylor, and I’m sure it’s one of the cuter pieces I’ve bought lately. It has that fun, girly vibe without feeling like it’s trying too hard, which I really liked.

The little design details stood out to me the most, especially the shape and the fabric touches. I wore it out the first night and got a few compliments, so I guess it was a win. The fit was mostly right too, at least close enough that I felt comfortable in it.
CARLSON
March 24, 2026
"Color was way different in person"
I ordered from saylor.nyc because the dress looked like the prettiest soft blue online, and I kept picturing it with these sandals I already have, which is maybe why I was so disappointed when it showed up.

In person, the color was more of a dull grey-blue, not really the fresh blue shade from the photos. I know screens can make colors look a little different, and lighting is always a thing, but this didn’t feel like a small difference. It changed the whole feel of the dress.

For the price, I just expected the photos to be more accurate. I kept trying it on in different rooms like maybe the light would help, but no, it still looked off. I wouldn’t order again
VASQUEZ
March 16, 2026
"Nice dress overall, just not quite the fit I expected"
I ordered a dress and the fabric feels really nice, not that cheap thin kind you sometimes get online. The stitching looked good too, so that was a plus. I’m happy with it overall... just took one star off because the fit was a little different than I thought it would be. Still cute though.
jesse_Sadan75
March 04, 2026
"Cute styles, but I’m not totally sold yet"
I’ll give them this: some of the styles did catch my eye. But the overall shopping experience felt a little weird, like I was supposed to just trust the vibes and hand over my money. There wasn’t a ton of clear info, and support took its sweet time getting back to me, which is always comforting when you’re about to spend more than you planned. For the prices, I expected to feel a bit more confident. I might give them another shot someday, but for now I’m definitely not rushing back.
marina_Rasco00
February 24, 2026
"Nice dress for a special occasion"
I bought this dress for a wedding it did the job really well. It fit nicely and looked cute without feeling like I had to spend a fortune for one event. My only small complaint is that shipping could’ve been a little faster, so I’d just recommend ordering with some extra time if you need it for a specific date
adahagstrom1448
February 14, 2026
"Cute stuff, but hard to actually buy"
I’ve found a few things I really liked, but it feels like every time I’m ready to order, it’s either sold out or there’s only some random size left. I did sign up for restock emails, but I haven’t really gotten anywhere with that either. It’s a little frustrating because I do like the styles, I just wish they were easier to actually get...
Lori.kohler
January 22, 2026
"Really nice fabric"
i mean, the fabric was the first thing I noticed when my dress from saylor.nyc arrived. It feels soft and comfortable without feeling cheap or thin, and it lays really nicely on the skin.

I wore it for a few hours and never felt itchy or uncomfortable. It’s one of those pieces that still looks dressed up but doesn’t feel like a hassle to wear, so I’d definitely buy again.
BERNSTEIN
January 09, 2026
"Looked nice, but didn’t quite meet my expectations"
I really liked how it looked when I first got it, so I was hopeful. But after checking it out more closely, the stitching seemed a bit rushed and some of the seams weren’t very even. It’s still wearable and not terrible, but for the price, I expected the quality to feel a little better.
NicoleDevenport_27
December 20, 2025
"Order was wrong and nobody followed up"
I ordered one size and got a different one, which was frustrating. I reached out hoping it would get sorted, but there was no follow-up at all. Not the worst thing ever, but definitely annoying and not a great experience
PETERSON
December 18, 2025
"Shipping Took Longer Than Expected"
I try to be fair because delays can happen, but my order really took much longer to arrive than I expected. The tracking updates didn’t give me much to go on either, which made the wait more frustrating. The item itself was fine once it showed up, but the shipping experience was disappointing enough that I’d probably think twice before ordering again.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Saylor NYC?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.